Review of models for the analysis of ethical dilemmas

Jennifer Ruíz-Cano, Guillermo R. Cantú-Quintanilla, Diana Ávila-Montiel, José Domingo Gamboa-Marrufo, Luis E. Juárez-Villegas, Adalberto de Hoyos-Bermea, Adrián Chávez-López, Karla P. Estrada-Ramírez, Carlos A. Merelo-Arias, Myriam M. Altamirano-Bustamante, Nahum de la Vega-Morell, Ingris Peláez-Ballestas, Jessica H. Guadarrama-Orozco, Onofre Muñoz-Hernández, Juan Garduño-Espinosa

Research output: Contribution to journalShort survey

2 Citations (Scopus)

Abstract

© 2015 Hospital Infantil de México Federico Gómez. In pediatric medical practice it is common to encounter situations that represent a dilemma for health professionals. A dilemma occurs when ethical problems found in professional practice cause serious internal conflicts because they imply actions that contradict their colleagues, employees, or their own personal values and are classified as personal value conflicts, conflicts with other professionals, conflicts with clients and with organizations.A literature review allowed identifying different models to debate these types of dilemmas. The present work is a review of the search of scientific articles using databases such as Ebsco Host, ProQuest, Ovid, and InMex as well as metasearch tools such as metacrawler. The models found are as follows: Model of Anne Davis, Nijmegen method, Method of Diego Gracia, Integral method, Bochum Center Ethics model, Model of Brody and Payton, Model of Curtin and Flaherty, Model of Thompson and Thompson, SAD method, Model of Javier Morata, Model of Elaine Congress, IFSW model, Model of Loewenberg and Dolgoff, Ley Social Model, DOER method, Model of Brommer, Model of Corey and Callanan, Model of Pope and Vasquez, Model of Bush, Connell and Denney, Model of Ferrell, Gresham and Fraedrich, and Model of Hunt and Vitell.The key criteria shared in the different models are a) specifying the ethical dilemma, b) description of the facts, c) value definition, moral code and facts, decision making and d) identifying alternative solutions. In order to review the literature, some models are explained with the purpose of identifying and representing critical elements that clinical ethics committees could use in a practical manner in pediatric health institutions in Mexico.
Original languageAmerican English
Pages (from-to)89-98
Number of pages10
JournalBoletin Medico del Hospital Infantil de Mexico
DOIs
StatePublished - 1 Jan 2015
Externally publishedYes

Fingerprint

Ethical Analysis
Clinical Ethics Committees
Pediatrics
Professional Practice
Health
Mexico
Ethics
Decision Making
Databases
Conflict (Psychology)

Cite this

Ruíz-Cano, J., Cantú-Quintanilla, G. R., Ávila-Montiel, D., Gamboa-Marrufo, J. D., Juárez-Villegas, L. E., de Hoyos-Bermea, A., ... Garduño-Espinosa, J. (2015). Review of models for the analysis of ethical dilemmas. Boletin Medico del Hospital Infantil de Mexico, 89-98. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.bmhimx.2015.03.006
Ruíz-Cano, Jennifer ; Cantú-Quintanilla, Guillermo R. ; Ávila-Montiel, Diana ; Gamboa-Marrufo, José Domingo ; Juárez-Villegas, Luis E. ; de Hoyos-Bermea, Adalberto ; Chávez-López, Adrián ; Estrada-Ramírez, Karla P. ; Merelo-Arias, Carlos A. ; Altamirano-Bustamante, Myriam M. ; de la Vega-Morell, Nahum ; Peláez-Ballestas, Ingris ; Guadarrama-Orozco, Jessica H. ; Muñoz-Hernández, Onofre ; Garduño-Espinosa, Juan. / Review of models for the analysis of ethical dilemmas. In: Boletin Medico del Hospital Infantil de Mexico. 2015 ; pp. 89-98.
@article{75355211ef04484c8072e1daf76ee22c,
title = "Review of models for the analysis of ethical dilemmas",
abstract = "{\circledC} 2015 Hospital Infantil de M{\'e}xico Federico G{\'o}mez. In pediatric medical practice it is common to encounter situations that represent a dilemma for health professionals. A dilemma occurs when ethical problems found in professional practice cause serious internal conflicts because they imply actions that contradict their colleagues, employees, or their own personal values and are classified as personal value conflicts, conflicts with other professionals, conflicts with clients and with organizations.A literature review allowed identifying different models to debate these types of dilemmas. The present work is a review of the search of scientific articles using databases such as Ebsco Host, ProQuest, Ovid, and InMex as well as metasearch tools such as metacrawler. The models found are as follows: Model of Anne Davis, Nijmegen method, Method of Diego Gracia, Integral method, Bochum Center Ethics model, Model of Brody and Payton, Model of Curtin and Flaherty, Model of Thompson and Thompson, SAD method, Model of Javier Morata, Model of Elaine Congress, IFSW model, Model of Loewenberg and Dolgoff, Ley Social Model, DOER method, Model of Brommer, Model of Corey and Callanan, Model of Pope and Vasquez, Model of Bush, Connell and Denney, Model of Ferrell, Gresham and Fraedrich, and Model of Hunt and Vitell.The key criteria shared in the different models are a) specifying the ethical dilemma, b) description of the facts, c) value definition, moral code and facts, decision making and d) identifying alternative solutions. In order to review the literature, some models are explained with the purpose of identifying and representing critical elements that clinical ethics committees could use in a practical manner in pediatric health institutions in Mexico.",
author = "Jennifer Ru{\'i}z-Cano and Cant{\'u}-Quintanilla, {Guillermo R.} and Diana {\'A}vila-Montiel and Gamboa-Marrufo, {Jos{\'e} Domingo} and Ju{\'a}rez-Villegas, {Luis E.} and {de Hoyos-Bermea}, Adalberto and Adri{\'a}n Ch{\'a}vez-L{\'o}pez and Estrada-Ram{\'i}rez, {Karla P.} and Merelo-Arias, {Carlos A.} and Altamirano-Bustamante, {Myriam M.} and {de la Vega-Morell}, Nahum and Ingris Pel{\'a}ez-Ballestas and Guadarrama-Orozco, {Jessica H.} and Onofre Mu{\~n}oz-Hern{\'a}ndez and Juan Gardu{\~n}o-Espinosa",
year = "2015",
month = "1",
day = "1",
doi = "10.1016/j.bmhimx.2015.03.006",
language = "American English",
pages = "89--98",
journal = "Boletin Medico del Hospital Infantil de Mexico",
issn = "1665-1146",
publisher = "Hospital Infantil de Mexico Federico Gomez",

}

Ruíz-Cano, J, Cantú-Quintanilla, GR, Ávila-Montiel, D, Gamboa-Marrufo, JD, Juárez-Villegas, LE, de Hoyos-Bermea, A, Chávez-López, A, Estrada-Ramírez, KP, Merelo-Arias, CA, Altamirano-Bustamante, MM, de la Vega-Morell, N, Peláez-Ballestas, I, Guadarrama-Orozco, JH, Muñoz-Hernández, O & Garduño-Espinosa, J 2015, 'Review of models for the analysis of ethical dilemmas', Boletin Medico del Hospital Infantil de Mexico, pp. 89-98. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.bmhimx.2015.03.006

Review of models for the analysis of ethical dilemmas. / Ruíz-Cano, Jennifer; Cantú-Quintanilla, Guillermo R.; Ávila-Montiel, Diana; Gamboa-Marrufo, José Domingo; Juárez-Villegas, Luis E.; de Hoyos-Bermea, Adalberto; Chávez-López, Adrián; Estrada-Ramírez, Karla P.; Merelo-Arias, Carlos A.; Altamirano-Bustamante, Myriam M.; de la Vega-Morell, Nahum; Peláez-Ballestas, Ingris; Guadarrama-Orozco, Jessica H.; Muñoz-Hernández, Onofre; Garduño-Espinosa, Juan.

In: Boletin Medico del Hospital Infantil de Mexico, 01.01.2015, p. 89-98.

Research output: Contribution to journalShort survey

TY - JOUR

T1 - Review of models for the analysis of ethical dilemmas

AU - Ruíz-Cano, Jennifer

AU - Cantú-Quintanilla, Guillermo R.

AU - Ávila-Montiel, Diana

AU - Gamboa-Marrufo, José Domingo

AU - Juárez-Villegas, Luis E.

AU - de Hoyos-Bermea, Adalberto

AU - Chávez-López, Adrián

AU - Estrada-Ramírez, Karla P.

AU - Merelo-Arias, Carlos A.

AU - Altamirano-Bustamante, Myriam M.

AU - de la Vega-Morell, Nahum

AU - Peláez-Ballestas, Ingris

AU - Guadarrama-Orozco, Jessica H.

AU - Muñoz-Hernández, Onofre

AU - Garduño-Espinosa, Juan

PY - 2015/1/1

Y1 - 2015/1/1

N2 - © 2015 Hospital Infantil de México Federico Gómez. In pediatric medical practice it is common to encounter situations that represent a dilemma for health professionals. A dilemma occurs when ethical problems found in professional practice cause serious internal conflicts because they imply actions that contradict their colleagues, employees, or their own personal values and are classified as personal value conflicts, conflicts with other professionals, conflicts with clients and with organizations.A literature review allowed identifying different models to debate these types of dilemmas. The present work is a review of the search of scientific articles using databases such as Ebsco Host, ProQuest, Ovid, and InMex as well as metasearch tools such as metacrawler. The models found are as follows: Model of Anne Davis, Nijmegen method, Method of Diego Gracia, Integral method, Bochum Center Ethics model, Model of Brody and Payton, Model of Curtin and Flaherty, Model of Thompson and Thompson, SAD method, Model of Javier Morata, Model of Elaine Congress, IFSW model, Model of Loewenberg and Dolgoff, Ley Social Model, DOER method, Model of Brommer, Model of Corey and Callanan, Model of Pope and Vasquez, Model of Bush, Connell and Denney, Model of Ferrell, Gresham and Fraedrich, and Model of Hunt and Vitell.The key criteria shared in the different models are a) specifying the ethical dilemma, b) description of the facts, c) value definition, moral code and facts, decision making and d) identifying alternative solutions. In order to review the literature, some models are explained with the purpose of identifying and representing critical elements that clinical ethics committees could use in a practical manner in pediatric health institutions in Mexico.

AB - © 2015 Hospital Infantil de México Federico Gómez. In pediatric medical practice it is common to encounter situations that represent a dilemma for health professionals. A dilemma occurs when ethical problems found in professional practice cause serious internal conflicts because they imply actions that contradict their colleagues, employees, or their own personal values and are classified as personal value conflicts, conflicts with other professionals, conflicts with clients and with organizations.A literature review allowed identifying different models to debate these types of dilemmas. The present work is a review of the search of scientific articles using databases such as Ebsco Host, ProQuest, Ovid, and InMex as well as metasearch tools such as metacrawler. The models found are as follows: Model of Anne Davis, Nijmegen method, Method of Diego Gracia, Integral method, Bochum Center Ethics model, Model of Brody and Payton, Model of Curtin and Flaherty, Model of Thompson and Thompson, SAD method, Model of Javier Morata, Model of Elaine Congress, IFSW model, Model of Loewenberg and Dolgoff, Ley Social Model, DOER method, Model of Brommer, Model of Corey and Callanan, Model of Pope and Vasquez, Model of Bush, Connell and Denney, Model of Ferrell, Gresham and Fraedrich, and Model of Hunt and Vitell.The key criteria shared in the different models are a) specifying the ethical dilemma, b) description of the facts, c) value definition, moral code and facts, decision making and d) identifying alternative solutions. In order to review the literature, some models are explained with the purpose of identifying and representing critical elements that clinical ethics committees could use in a practical manner in pediatric health institutions in Mexico.

U2 - 10.1016/j.bmhimx.2015.03.006

DO - 10.1016/j.bmhimx.2015.03.006

M3 - Short survey

C2 - 29425998

SP - 89

EP - 98

JO - Boletin Medico del Hospital Infantil de Mexico

JF - Boletin Medico del Hospital Infantil de Mexico

SN - 1665-1146

ER -

Ruíz-Cano J, Cantú-Quintanilla GR, Ávila-Montiel D, Gamboa-Marrufo JD, Juárez-Villegas LE, de Hoyos-Bermea A et al. Review of models for the analysis of ethical dilemmas. Boletin Medico del Hospital Infantil de Mexico. 2015 Jan 1;89-98. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.bmhimx.2015.03.006